The Fill-In Boyfriend
Page 4

“Okay. So, will you try to look at me like you’re madly in love?”
“Captain America and you were madly in love?”
I opened my mouth—my first instinct was to say “of course”—but stopped myself because it wasn’t true. Bradley and I were . . . Well, we were happy. At least I’d thought we were before tonight. I put on my best teasing smile, glad that my feelings, which had tried to take over in the parking lot, were back in my control. “Do you not have a reference point for that emotion?”
He concentrated for a moment then turned a smoldering gaze on me. Wow. He was good.
“That may be a little thick.”
He softened the intensity of his gaze and for the first time I noticed his eyes were blue. Not good. Bradley had brown eyes.
“That bad, huh?”
“No. Your look is great.” Meaning he did know what being in love felt like. I was the one without a reference point. “Your eye color is frustrating.”
“I’ve never been told that before. Thanks.”
“I’m sorry. I’m sure girls tell you that they’re dreamy or whatever.” And they were. “It’s just . . .”
“Bradley has emerald green? No, melty chocolate brown?”
I laughed because he had grabbed his chest and said it in a melodramatic voice. “Yes. Very melty.”
He met my eyes. “Like yours.”
“Well, his are more chocolate, mine are more sepia, but . . .” I shook my head, trying to get back on subject. “Just try not to make eye contact with anyone.”
“Because that won’t be creepy. You think your friends remember the eye color of a guy they’ve never met? Did you really talk about his eyes that much?”
“No. I mean, well, they’ve seen a few pictures.”
“They’ve seen pictures?” His eyes widened. “And you think we’re going to get away with this how?”
“Well, they were from a distance. And one was of half his face.” Much to my frustration, he wasn’t a fan of having his picture taken. “It’s been a while since they’ve seen them. I think you look similar enough that it will work. But work on the non-creepy version of the no-eye-contact thing.”
He took my hand in his, kissed it, gave me his smoldering stare, and said, “Well, I only have eyes for you anyway.”
He was really good. I laughed. “I see my friends. Let’s go.”
“Why didn’t your friends think I existed if they’ve seen pics?” he asked as we made our way through dancing bodies.
“Because you went to UCLA and I was usually the one visiting you. When you did come up here, you wanted to spend our time together, not with my friends.”
“So I’m a snob. Got it.”
“I didn’t say that.”
“When you came to visit me, did we hang out with my friends?”
“No. We rarely saw each other. We didn’t want to have to deal with other people when we did.”
“Okay, so you were my secret.”
“No, it’s how I wanted it too. And besides, you just drove three hours to come to my prom, so you were obviously planning on meeting all my friends.” It was weirding me out that we were talking like he really was Bradley. I shook my head. “He was planning to meet my friends.”
“And yet he broke up with you in the parking lot before he actually did.”
I bit the inside of my cheek. Ten more steps and we’d reach the group, so I couldn’t explain to him that I had treated Bradley poorly. That the first thing I’d said to him after not having seen him for two weeks was that my friends were going to die. It was because he’d looked so amazing. But I should’ve said that instead. I shouldn’t have worried what my friends were going to think. It was hard not to, though, when I’d spent two months fielding questions about his existence, two months telling them all about him. All because of Jules. I shouldn’t have let her get to me like I did.
Claire noticed me first and her eyes seemed to light up in relief when she saw my date. We were the closest, so she was always the one defending me. “Gia!” At her exclamation everyone else turned around.
The look from Jules was priceless. It was a smug smile followed by a slight drop of her jaw. And for once, Laney didn’t have the pity face. I smiled a huge smile.
“Everyone, this is Bradley.”
He raised his hand in a small wave and I didn’t know if it was to be funny or if it was unintentional, but when he said “Nice to meet you all,” his voice was low and husky.
Claire widened her eyes at me like way-to-go-Gia was written in them.
Jules got her inner snob back quickly as she looked him up and down. I held my breath, waiting for her to say he looked nothing like his pictures or nothing like the guys I normally dated. Instead she said, “I’m surprised you wanted to come to a high school prom.”
He looked me straight in the eyes and slipped his arm down my back, hooking me around the waist. “It was important to Gia.” With the words he pulled me against his side. My back tingled with his touch. My first instinct was to yank away, but that wouldn’t have been my reaction to Bradley. I would’ve leaned into him. I would’ve sighed happily. I made myself do both.
Jules smirked. “Is that the theme of your relationship? ‘The importance of Gia’?” She actually did air quotes.
Garrett, Jules’s date, laughed but then stopped quickly when another one of the guys smacked him on the back.